Court of Appeals Finds Internally Inconsistent Reports Cannot Support PTD

Permanent total disability compensation is compensation of last resort and can be awarded only upon a showing by the claimant that he/she is incapable of sustained remunerative employment.  Although neither the workers’ compensation statute nor the administrative rules define sustained remunerative employment, the Ohio Supreme Court has held that part-time work may constitute sustained remunerative employment.  The 10th District Court of Appeals has established that the capability to work 4 or more hours/day of part-time work is sufficient to constitute sustained remunerative employment and negate a claimant’s application for PTD benefits.

In State ex. rel. Honda of Am., Mfg., Inc. v. Indus. Comm, 2017-Ohio-8972, the 10th District Court of Appeals revisited the effect of part-time work in a PTD claim.  Administratively, the Commission granted a claimant PTD compensation based on his physician’s report that the claimant was unable to performed sustained remunerative employment.  However, the same physician also authored a physical capacity questionnaire finding the claimant could work part-time, 4 to 5 hours per day.  Because of the apparent inconsistencies between the two reports, the company challenged the Commission’s order in a mandamus action, seeking a writ of mandamus vacating the order.

The court of appeals granted a limited writ requiring the Commission to vacate its decision, hold a new hearing, and issue a new order.  Noting its prior rulings regarding part-time work, the court found that the two reports from the claimant’s physician were irreconcilable.  It is well settled that internally inconsistent reports do not constitute “some evidence” supporting a Commission order.  Interestingly, by the time the matter was before the court of appeals, the Commission had conceded that the order awarding PTD compensation was not supported by the evidence.


  • The Supreme Court of the United States Blocks OSHA’S ETS Regarding Vaccines but Enforces CMS MandateRead more


  • Bugbee & Conkle Proudly Welcomes The 2021 Solheim Cup to ToledoRead more

Newsletter Signup

Signup here to be added to receive our quarterly publications Safety Sense, The Employer, and Comp Connection, as well as webinar and event invitations.